If you’ve been arrested for petty theft for the first time, you may wonder if hiring a criminal defense attorney is necessary. After all, petty theft is often considered a minor offense, and you might assume the case is straightforward. However, even for a first offense, having a skilled attorney can make a significant difference in protecting your rights and achieving the best possible outcome.
Here’s why hiring an attorney is a smart move, even for seemingly minor charges like petty theft.
What Is Petty Theft in California?
In California, petty theft refers to the theft of property, goods, or money valued at less than $950. Common examples include shoplifting and stealing small items from stores or individuals. While petty theft is a misdemeanor, the potential penalties can include:
- Jail time of up to six months.
- Fines and court fees.
- Probation.
- Community service.
- A restraining order barring you from returning to the store or location of the incident.
For first-time offenders, jail time is unlikely, but that doesn’t mean the charge is without consequences. A petty theft conviction results in a criminal record, which can impact future job prospects, housing opportunities, and more.
Misconceptions About Defending Petty Theft Charges
Many people facing their first petty theft charge believe they don’t need an attorney. This assumption often comes from misconceptions about the legal system or the belief that there is no viable defense.
Caught Red-Handed? You May Still Have Options
Even if you think the case against you is airtight, there are often defense strategies available. For instance:
- There may be insufficient evidence to prove you committed the crime.
- You may have been accused by mistake or due to a misunderstanding.
- An attorney can negotiate alternative resolutions, such as diversion programs, that avoid a criminal record.
Without legal representation, you could miss opportunities to reduce or dismiss your charges.
Benefits of Hiring a Criminal Defense Attorney
Working with an experienced attorney for a petty theft charge offers numerous advantages, even for first-time offenders.
Legal Expertise and Strategy
A defense attorney understands the complexities of criminal law and can analyze the specifics of your case to craft the best defense. This includes challenging evidence, negotiating with prosecutors, and exploring alternatives like diversion programs or plea deals.
Minimized Court Appearances
One often-overlooked benefit of hiring an attorney is that they can attend most court appearances on your behalf. This means you won’t need to take time off work, arrange transportation, or experience the stress of appearing in court.
Reduced Long-Term Consequences
A skilled attorney’s ultimate goal is to minimize the impact of the charge on your life. This could include reducing penalties, avoiding a criminal record, or securing a complete dismissal of the charges.
Why You Shouldn’t Face Petty Theft Charges Alone
The consequences of a petty theft conviction extend far beyond immediate penalties. A criminal record can have lasting implications, and navigating the legal system without professional guidance increases the risk of unfavorable outcomes.
By working with a defense attorney, you gain a knowledgeable advocate who can:
- Protect your rights throughout the legal process.
- Provide clarity on your options and potential outcomes.
- Work toward the most favorable resolution for your case.
Take the First Step Toward Resolving Your Case
If you’ve been charged with petty theft, your next step should be contacting an experienced criminal defense attorney. Even for a first offense, legal representation is crucial to protecting your future and achieving the best possible outcome.
Contact Simmons Wagner, LLP at (949) 439-5857 for a free consultation. Our team will evaluate your case, explore all available defenses, and guide you toward a resolution that minimizes the impact on your life.

