Few accusations carry more personal and professional consequences than domestic violence. A single claim—true or not—can damage relationships, employment opportunities, and your standing in the community.
Unfortunately, false or exaggerated allegations do occur, often during heated breakups, custody disputes, or emotional confrontations. At Simmons Wagner, LLP, we know how devastating these accusations can be and how critical a strong, strategic defense is from day one.
The Real-World Consequences of False Allegations
In California, domestic violence charges are taken extremely seriously. Police are often required to make an arrest when responding to a domestic dispute if they believe violence occurred. That means even without physical evidence, an accusation alone can result in immediate legal trouble.
Consequences of a false accusation may include:
- Arrest and temporary restraining orders
- Mandatory no-contact conditions
- Loss of custody or visitation rights
- Damage to your reputation and career
- Potential jail time and fines if convicted
Even if the allegations are later proven false, the emotional and financial toll can be immense. That’s why it’s essential to contact an experienced defense attorney immediately.
Understanding Why False Claims Happen
False domestic violence accusations can arise in several contexts, including:
- Child custody disputes: One parent may exaggerate or fabricate abuse claims to gain an advantage in family court.
- Relationship retaliation: In high-conflict breakups, accusations may be used to punish or control the other party.
- Misunderstandings or self-defense: What began as mutual arguing or self-protection may be mischaracterized as assault.
- Manipulation or revenge: Sadly, some individuals weaponize the system to harm another’s reputation.
Simmons Wagner, LLP approaches every case by uncovering the truth behind the accusation. Our team carefully examines the relationship dynamics, evidence, and communication history to expose inconsistencies and motivations that undermine the accuser’s credibility.
How a Strong Legal Defense Makes a Difference
Defending against domestic violence charges requires more than simply denying the claim. It takes a proactive, evidence-driven approach that challenges every element of the prosecution’s case. At Simmons Wagner, LLP, we build defenses by:
- Analyzing police reports and body camera footage for errors, inconsistencies, or bias.
- Examining witness statements to identify conflicting or unreliable testimony.
- Reviewing digital communications—texts, emails, social media—for context that contradicts the accusation.
- Highlighting lack of physical evidence, such as injuries or medical reports inconsistent with the alleged incident.
- Demonstrating motive, showing how jealousy, anger, or custody battles may have influenced false claims.
When necessary, we also work with forensic experts to review evidence like photos, timestamps, or recordings that can prove your version of events.
The Role of Restraining Orders
In most cases, domestic violence accusations trigger immediate restraining orders. While temporary at first, these orders can become long-term if not challenged. Violating one—even accidentally—can lead to new criminal charges.
Our attorneys help clients navigate restraining order hearings by presenting evidence that disputes the accuser’s claims and demonstrates your credibility. Successfully contesting a restraining order can not only protect your freedom but also strengthen your defense in the related criminal case.
Protecting Your Future Starts Now
The longer you wait to build your defense, the harder it becomes to gather critical evidence and witness testimony. Early intervention by an experienced criminal defense team can make all the difference between conviction and dismissal.
At Simmons Wagner, LLP, we understand what’s at stake. Our attorneys handle domestic violence defense with professionalism, discretion, and determination—fighting to protect your reputation, your rights, and your future.
If you’ve been falsely accused of domestic violence in California, contact Simmons Wagner, LLP today at (949) 439-5857 for a confidential consultation. We’ll review your case, explain your options, and begin building the defense you deserve.